The Science of Influence: Turning Data Into Decisions That Stick

As data analysts, we often define our work by the numbers, models, dashboards, and SQL queries. But here’s the truth: your analysis is only as impactful as your ability to persuade others to act on it.

You can build the most elegant model or deliver a perfectly visualised dashboard, but if your stakeholders misunderstand or ignore your insights, your influence ends at the spreadsheet.

That’s where influence and persuasion come in, not manipulation, but the science of guiding people toward better, data-informed decisions.

One of the most influential thinkers in this space is Robert Cialdini, whose research on why people say “yes” has shaped modern behavioural science. In his classic book Influence: The Psychology of Persuasion, he identifies key principles that help us connect, motivate, and drive action.

In this article, we’ll explore two of these principles, Reciprocity and Consistency, and how they can help analysts move from being “data providers” to trusted business partners.

1. Reciprocity: Give First, Influence Later

The principle of reciprocity is simple but powerful: when you give something of value, people naturally feel inclined to return the favour.

In analytics, this doesn’t mean giving away freebies, it’s about offering insights, clarity, or help before asking for support or commitment in return.

Example 1: Sharing insights before a major decision

Imagine you know a key stakeholder is preparing for an upcoming strategy review. Before they even ask, you share a short, one-page snapshot of relevant performance data with a few thoughtful observations, something that helps them walk into that meeting more informed.

You might say, “I noticed a few interesting trends in your product performance last quarter - thought you might find them useful as you prepare for next week’s discussion.”

Later, when you need that same stakeholder’s input or approval for a new analysis project, they’ll likely be far more receptive. You’ve already demonstrated that you add value, and people tend to reciprocate.

Example 2: Offering proactive help in team planning

Suppose your operations team is preparing for a quarterly planning cycle. Rather than waiting to be asked for data, you volunteer to run a quick exploratory analysis to highlight where processes are slowing down or where demand is shifting.

By giving them a head start, you’re not only making their job easier but also positioning yourself as a collaborative partner. When you later ask for time, resources, or data access, the goodwill you’ve built makes those requests much easier to fulfil.

Small, thoughtful acts of value compound over time. Reciprocity isn’t about keeping score, it’s about building relationships where cooperation feels natural.

2. Consistency: Help Stakeholders Stay True to Their Goals

People want to act in ways that align with what they’ve already said or done. This need for consistency is a powerful psychological driver, and one analysts can use to encourage follow-through on data-driven recommendations.

Example 1: Reinforcing agreed metrics of success

Imagine your leadership team has previously agreed that improving customer retention is a key business priority. Later, your analysis reveals that resources are being disproportionately spent on acquiring new customers instead.

Instead of saying, “We’re focusing on the wrong thing,” you could frame it as: "In our last strategy session, you highlighted retention as a core focus area. The latest data suggests our current spending patterns might be pulling us away from that goal. Would you like to explore how we can realign?”

By connecting your insight to an existing commitment, you reduce resistance, you’re helping them stay consistent with their own priorities.

Example 2: Aligning product decisions with previous feedback

Let’s say a product manager wants to add new features despite earlier customer feedback indicating usability issues. You can invoke consistency by referencing that prior insight: “Earlier this year, the team agreed that simplifying the user experience was a top priority based on customer feedback. Adding these new features might make the interface more complex, should we revisit the original goal before moving forward?”

This gentle reminder keeps discussions grounded in shared values and previously stated objectives, making data-backed decisions feel like natural extensions of earlier commitments.

Why This Matters

Your role as an analyst isn’t just to answer questions, it’s to shape better decisions. By applying behavioural science principles like reciprocity and consistency, you can:

• Build trust and credibility with stakeholders

• Encourage collaboration instead of resistance

• Reinforce stakeholder commitments and avoid rework

• Protect your time by focusing on high-impact work

• Ensure your insights lead to real, measurable business outcomes

  
  

Next Steps: Master the Art of Influence in Analytics

Influence is a skill, and like any skill, it can be developed. When combined with strong analytical thinking, it becomes a superpower that turns insights into action.

In my Making Analysis Work for Business workshops, I help analysts strengthen their soft skills and adopt working practices that build trust, confidence, and alignment with stakeholders. To learn more click here or feel free to email me at steve@sophic.co.uk

Or for in depth strategies on how to master the art of influence in your role as a data analyst subscribe to my LinkedIn newsletter by clicking the link below and read edition 11.

The Analyst: Insightful Bytes

Your analysis deserves to make an impact. With the right approach, it will.